My Opinion: Dealer.com Is The Best Website A Car Dealer Should Be Using
Showroom Logic does not build car dealer websites, so I am able to give my opinion openly about the best and the worst websites for car dealers. Although it may appear that we do, we simply don’t. We build microsites to work in conjunction with the main website a car dealer uses, and our microsites appear to be a simple classified listing. We do not brand the dealership at all, we brand their cars.
Showroom Logic is a consulting and a car dealer SEO Company, it’s that simple. When we sign up a dealer our results are so great that they call us back to see what else we can do.
I’ve been wanting to write this article for a while now, but this morning I saw a cool thing that Dealer.com does with their urls.
While servicing one of our newest car dealers, I was looking at my live stats to see how their microsite was doing. I noticed that we just got a visit from a VIN search.
I was suprise to even see that because we do not target VIN numbers for searches. Anyway, we came up second on a Google search (Car Fax was 1).
I noticed the third listing was a dealer website, and I could tell by looking at the url that it was an actual vehicle listing on a car dealer’s website. I went ahead an clicked it and POOF, I was redirected to the homepage of the dealership.
Do you know what a 301 redirect is?
Think about this. You have a car dealership that typically sells 100 cars a month. When those vehicles get sold, the listings are eventually deleted. You must realize that all of your inventory will be indexed in Google, Yahoo and Bing. Even if it only ranks on page 50, it’s still indexed. So what happens when the Google Bot or Yahoo Slurp comes back and spiders your website to find new listings to index?
I’ll tell you what happens. They find broken links and 404 errors. Search Engines hate that! Dealer.com appears to create a 301 redirect back to the homepage. Another words, when a user clicks the link that is no longer there, the 301 tells the search engines that “this vehicle moved here” and it redirects it.
We’ve been using this technology for a long time, but it’s cool to see someone else doing it (Especially a dealer website provider). We handle our redirects a bit differently, but I cannot say what we do because that’s out little secret.
There are other things a like about Dealer.com websites, but the one other thing worth mentioning is their automated Google Adwords tool. It’s great to see a dealer website provider offering this, and it can save you thousands of dollars a month from marketing company fees to manage and run these campaigns.
Showroom Logic has a tool like that, and we can use it with any dealer website, so if you are stuck in a contract with one of those other website providers you can contact us and we’ll set you up.
I wish there was another website provider that I could compare to Dealer.com, but there isn’t one. Here is my opinions on the others:
- Cobalt: They haven’t changed a thing in over 2 years. Same old templates, nothing new to mention. If you want to stay ahead in this business you need to constantly make changes and roll them out to everybody. One of the largest volume car dealerships in Florida uses Cobalt, and they are so naive they love it. I have been doing extensive keyword research in my area and they are nowhere to be found. I feel they could be selling another 50 – 75 cars a month if they tried something new. My dealer in Tampa Bay sold over 120 used cars alone in the Tampa Market, and I am proud to say that. If you are a Dealer.com rep in Central Florida, contact me and I’ll tell you who they are.
- Izmo Cars: They make great looking websites, but they don’t rank for inventory listings. Until they make a massive change in their coding, they never will. One of my dealers uses Izmo for their main website, and I was shocked to learn they don’t even have a backend to log on to and make changes. You have to call your rep every time, in INDIA!! I am doing some SEO work for a car dealer that uses Izmo for their main site. Last month I found a microsite they were using that was a Dealer.com site. I switched all backlinks to that website instead of their main Izmo site because I know I could juice that one up better.
- BZ Results: I worked for a dealership that used them about 2 years ago. They were stuck in a very expensive 3 year contract, and it was by far the worst possible website provider out their. Needless to say, the 3 rooftop dealership went out of business about 4 months ago. Whoever sold that contract made a killing. They put $150,000.00 down and had to pay $8,000.00 a month for three years.
I did see some new companies at the NADA Convention in Orlando, but I haven’t found anyone using them.
Did I miss anyone? Leave a comment and let me know.
If anyone represents any of the website providers above, I would love to debate. Everything I said is my opinion, and I don’t pretend to know everything. But…I’ve been doing this since 1994. I’ve been around to see how everything evolved in many different industries. I’ve sold printing online, seafood and cars. Now I only work with car dealers.
Private debates are welcome. Email mike@showroomlogic.com

We have the perfect solution for sold inventory. URLs still work but it shows similar vehicles to the one that was sold! Having dead links after they are sold is a bad solution.
Example:
http://www.mykcford.com/2010-Ford-Focus-SEL-Kansas-City-MO/vd/3953311
Thanks for your reply Matt. Nice to see another company with some great stuff!
Mike,
At Liquid Motors we have been doing this for sometime now. We do it a little different in the sense that if that listing no longer exists we don’t just send them to the home page of the site but to the actual results page for that Make and Model. This allows a customer who clicked on an add for an Audi A6 to actually see an Audi A6 very quickly.
Example of a listing that is no longer in the dealer inventory: http://iraaudi.com/Certified/2007_AUDI_A6_4dr_Sdn_3_2L_quattro__/Peabody_MA/LISTING-107434366/VehicleDetails.aspx
You will also notice that the URL is very Bot or Spider friendly. We get a lot of referrals from Google Images due to this type of URL.
In addition to our complete Internet marketing solutions our Optisite product line are all completley custom. There is no pick from this or that, it is an 8 week custom build time and process to create the exact look and feel of what the dealer wants.
Please include us in any of your comparisons. http://www.LiquidMotors.com
P.S. Matt, sorry I missed you this year at NADA considering we were only 15 feet away LOL I guess that is a good sign for both of us that we were so busy!
Thanks for your input Terry. I’ve never heard of you company but I’ll do some research!
What is your opinion on Reynolds Web Solution?
Steve, how do they handle their sold inventory? If you’re not sure you should call and ask them. It wouldn’t be easy for me to find one.
For starters, the little YouTube video you have on the top left is blocking your New Inventory and Pre-Owned Inventory drop down links. The links end up behind the video.
This happens on Firefox (not explorer), so you should have them fix the issue asap.
I just dug a bit deeper and looked at your inventory. The actual inventory will never rank on search engines, for 2 reasons:
1) Duplicate Title Tags: Every single vehicle you have in inventory has the exact same Title Tag. Your title tag says “Pre-Owned Inventory 2 Bay Ridge Honda Brooklyn New York” on all of your vehicles. It should have a unique title tag for every vehicle, like “Used 2005 Honda Accord Brooklyn New York Bay Ridge Honda”
2) Sloppy URL’s: Your URL’s should have keywords in them for each of your inventory. This is what your URL looks like for a 2008 Honda Accord: http://www.bayridgehonda.com/Preowned-Inventory-2.aspx?InventoryId=30668785
It should be bayridgehonda.com/used-cars/2008-honda-accord.htm or something similar, but you get the idea.
This is just the tip of the iceberg. If I were you I would find another vendor quickly. You are missing the boat with long tail local keyword searches.
Remember Steve, I am not affiliated with any website providers, so I have no motive to suggest another company for financial gains. You need to contact any of the above vendors, and at least inquire.
Keyword stuffing, long, useless urls strings are bad. also over use of meta tag info doesnt help.
I would think for a new car dealer, but not a preowned. We have a late model inventory of almost 300 cars in Tampa Bay Florida, and out in-house website and our microsite rocks! Thanks again Showroom Logic for the SEO services and advice